SHD Logistics is part of the Informa Markets Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

IFOY 2016 nominees revealed

IFOY 2016 nominees revealed

The IFOY organisation has announced the nominations for the IFOY Award 2016. Thirteen trucks and solutions from BYD, Crown, Jungheinrich, SSI Schäfer, Still and Toyota Material Handling have been chosen for the final round from all the entries.

"All in all, 16 companies submitted entries this year and put forward an extremely wide range of products for the award," says Anita Würmser, Chairperson of the IFOY Jury. These 13 vehicles and solutions are the best of the best in terms of innovation."

Counter Balanced Trucks

The jury has nominated a total of three vehicles in the "Counter Balanced Trucks" category, and a truck made in China has made it into the final round for the first time in the history of IFOY. The three-wheeled ECB18C electric fork lift truck from BYD with a load capacity of 1.8t was launched in December 2015 and is powered by a maintenance-free iron-phosphate battery. There is no longer any need to change the battery, as the 80V three-phase technology permits intermediate charging in just one hour and without memory effect.

A further nominee and test candidate is the Crown C-5 four-wheel LPG counter-balanced truck with a load capacity of 3t. The gas-powered forklift has been on the market since June 2015 and boasts an inhouse-developed 2.4-litre engine, a robust powertrain, separate cooling systems for engine and transmission, and the typical Crown comfort level modelled on concepts used in the automotive industry.

The third forklift nomination went to the Traigo 48 from Toyota Material Handling. The first truck with a 48V lithium ion battery was launched in October 2015. The all-rounder can lift 1.6t up to heights of 7.5m, and its new electronic power steering makes it extremely agile. It doesn't need a battery change and can be rapidly charged even in short breaks.

Warehouse Trucks

The jury announced a total of five nominations for warehouse trucks – three in the "highlifters" and two in the "lowlifters" category.

Jungheinrich made it into the final round of the intralogistics "Oscars" with the totally newly developed EKX 516 electric order picker/fork lift truck. Lightweight design with vibration damping, the latest synchronous motor technology and top performance parameters mean that the man-up narrow aisle stacker sets a new benchmark: it can lift 1.6t to a height of 17.5m, has a top lifting speed of 0.6m/s and has 30% higher driving speeds. In addition, the manufacturer promises savings of €7,000 a year with its 2Shift1Charge guarantee.

Still has earned a further nomination with its EXV-SF16i highlifter truck. It has a top speed of 10km/h, can be used in both pedestrian and onboard mode, and achieves a 25% higher transshipment performance than its predecessor, the EGV-S. The pneumatically cushioned operator platform with height-adjustable sidebars and the patented load capacity indicator are new. The machine also automatically adapts its travel speed in curves and depending on lifting height. One interesting feature is the language-neutral colour display showing operator information and warnings.

Nomination number three goes to the BT Staxio SPE 140L from Toyota Material Handling. The compact and extremely agile electric highlifter with platform and initial lift feature reaches speeds of up to 10km/h and lifting heights of up to 5.4m, with series-produced trucks achieving heights of up to 6m. An automatic speed reduction feature for cornering provides protection for the driver. The use of lithium-ion battery technology means battery changes are a thing of the past.

In the "Warehouse Trucks, lowlifters" category, the jury has announced nominations for Crown and Jungheinrich.

The Crown RT 4020 fork lift truck with driver platform launched as recently as October 2015 can lift 2t and is the newest Crown product in this category for years. It has a top speed of 12.5km/h, and the chassis width of just 780mm means it can easily manoeuvre in tight spaces, as is the case when loading and unloading trucks, for example.

There is also a nomination for the optimised Jungheinrich EZS 5100 tugger train solution with GTE trailers launched in February of last year. The EZS 5100 has a traction capacity of 10t, making it a high-performance tugger train for the full range of applications. The electrohydraulic auto-lift feature of the GTE 312 trailer lifts loads cleanly and rapidly, and ensures that each trailer can be controlled individually.

Special Vehicles

The first nomination in the new IFOY category goes to the Jungheinrich EJQ 325. The Deutsche Bahn rail company in Dortmund presented the Jungheinrich special design team with a major challenge: the development and realisation of a device for changing the IC/ICE wheel sets. The task definition included precision load pickup and individual loading of the ICE wheel sets as well as the wheel set changer each weighing 2.5t over a lifting height of 550mm. The biggest challenge was longitudinal and traverse travel with a 2.4m-long load in a work aisle with a width of just 2.9m.

A further nomination is for Still's horizontal order picker CX-S 16. The series-produced vehicle is additionally equipped with a vacuum pump, a crane boom and a tube lifter from Schmalz so that it can move loads with weights of up to 40kg. A scissor-lift mechanism lifts two pallets to an ergonomic height of up to 785mm. Using the suction tool, the operator can easily pick, transload or palletise bulky products or heavy items like boxes, sacks, buckets, drums or small load carriers at any location.

Intralogistics Solutions

This year, concepts from Crown, SSI Schäfer and Still made in into the final round for intralogistics system solutions.

Crown joins the race with its QuickPick Remote solution for Jumbo Supermarkten, the leading private supermarket chain in the Netherlands with over 580 locations. At the Veghel distribution centre, around 1.4 million non-perishable foods are picked and sent to 171 Jumbo locations every week. The market for fast-moving consumer goods is fiercely competitive, and delivery punctuality depends on smooth routines in the Jumbo order picking and distribution chain.

Tests had already shown that driverless transport systems generated inadequate efficiency gains. In response to this finding, Crown designed a semi-automatic solution based on GPC 3000 order pickers and the QuickPick remote system (a past IFOY winner).

Each Crown GPC 3000 transports four roller containers. With the help of a colour coding system, the order pickers simultaneously put together articles for multiple locations. In addition, the order picking process was partly redesigned. As a result, Jumbo has made a 7.5% gain in productivity while considerably reducing the burden on staff. The conversion of the next Jumbo distribution centre in Elst is already underway.

SSI Schäfer wins a nomination for the inhouse-developed fleet solution with Weasel driverless transport systems implemented at the NextLevel Logistik GmbH company in Eltmann near Schweinfurt. Be it containers, cartons, trays or other products of widely varying sizes up to 35kg – at NextLevel Logistik, Weasel is responsible for all transport tasks between incoming goods, the workplaces, goods dispatch, all the way through to waste disposal.

The fashion logistics service provider active in the fast-growing eCommerce segment now has at its disposal an in-plant transport system that – unlike conventional driverless transport systems – does not need any costly sensor technology or complex control systems. The complete hardware and software for the system was installed and went into operation within the space of just three days. One special characteristic of the solution is the automatic RFID group reading system at the goods receipt stage. A further major advantage from the point of view of NextLevel Logistik is the flexibility and easy scalability of the solution: Weasel is not rail-based and can therefore be flexibly integrated in existing infrastructures. The solution can grow together with the business volume, and seasonal performance peaks can easily be handled by using additional Weasels.

With around 430 million packages stored every year, the storage capacity at the Miehlen logistics centre of the Heuchemer Verpackung GmbH & Co. KG company had reached the limit. In the new extension building, Hamburg-based intralogistics specialist Still installed a new space-optimised 18m-high channel storage system with four pallet shuttles and two order picking stackers of the type MX-X in the high-bay warehouse and optimised the interplay of the two logistics centres.

External storage facilities were closed down and the entire logistics centralised in Miehlen. The IFOY Award-winning iGoEasy system, a combination of automated highlifter truck of the type EGV-S and an iPad as configuration and control unit were used for the flexible organisation of constantly recurring transport runs for production waste disposal and the provision of buffer supplies. As a system integrator, Still not only planned and installed the entire system but also handled the fine tuning between shuttle, racks, conveying technology, stackers and driverless transport systems.

One innovative feature is that the shuttles are equipped with sensors to detect overhangs, thereby minimising the space between goods consignments to ensure that optimum use is made of the valuable storage place in the rack channels. This has increased the storage density for the pallets with overhangs by up to 50%.

Final decision follows IFOY Test

Which trucks are ultimately chosen for the IFOY Award 2016 will depend in large measure on the results of the IFOY Test and IFOY Innovation Check, which all nominated trucks have to undergo over a period of one week on the grounds of the official logistics partner CeMAT in Hannover.

The IFOY Test measures the hard data and compares it with the data for rival machines. The IFOY Innovation Check prepared by the specialists from the Dortmund-based Fraunhofer Institute for Material Flow and Logistics (IML) as well as the Chair of Machine Elements and Technical Logistics at the Helmut Schmidt University in Hamburg, focuses solely on innovations and the degree of innovation relative to the market. In addition, the jury members drive all nominated vehicles themselves, putting them through their paces during the IFOY Test Week.

Among other things, the IFOY Award assesses innovative quality, technology, design, ergonomics, handling, safety, cost effectiveness and sustainability. The key criteria for intralogistics solutions include novel/innovative quality, customer benefit, sustainability and marketability of the solution.

The winner in each category will be chosen by a jury made up of 25 internationally reputed trade journalists and the leading logistics media from 16 countries around the globe. The IFOY Award will be presented on 31st May at the CeMAT opening ceremony in Hannover.

2016 nominations at a glance

Counter Balanced Trucks up to 3.5t

  • ECB18C, BYD Europe (electric)
  • C-5 Vierrad-LPG, Crown (LPG)
  • Traigo 48 Lithium Ion, Toyota Material Handling (electric)

Warehouse Trucks “highlifters”

  • EKX 516, Jungheinrich
  • EXV-SF 16i, Still
  • BT Staxio SPE 140L, Toyota Material Handling

Warehouse Trucks “lowlifters”

  • RT4020, Crown
  • EZS 5100 + GTE 312, Jungheinrich

Special Vehicle

  • EJQ, Jungheinrich
  • Ergopick, Still

Intralogistics Solutions

  • Crown: at the distribution centre of Dutch supermarket chain Jumbo Supermarkten in Veghel, Crown implemented a semi-automatic picking system for 1.4 million fast-moving products based on GPC 3000 order pickers with QuickPick remote system.
  • SSI Schäfer: within the space of just three days, SSI Schäfer implemented a highly flexible and cost-effective inhouse fleet solution with Weasel  driverless transport systems for fashion logistics service provider NextLevel Logistik GmbH in Eltmann near Schweinfurt for its operations in the fast-growing eCommerce segment.
  • Still: at the logistics centre of the Heuchemer Verpackung company in Miehlen, Still has realised an extension building with high-bay storage unit and pallet shuttle system; in addition, with the installed iGoEasy system, a range of conveying technologies and a variable number of shuttles in the high-bay store, Still has also made major progress towards the automation of warehouse processes.

Members of the jury:

  • Martin Althoff, Editor-in-Chief of Logistiek Totaal (Netherlands)
  • Vladimir Antonov, Editor-in-Chief of Sklad i Technika, (Russia)
  • Snejina Badjeva, Editor-in-Chief of LOGISTIKA magazine (Bulgaria)
  • Theo Egberts, IFOY tester and owner of Buro Andersom/Andersom Testing (Netherlands, without voting rights)
  • Sven Bennühr (proxy), Deutsche Logistik-Zeitung (DVZ) (Germany)
  • Thilo Jörgl, Editor-in-Chief of LOGISTIK HEUTE (Germany)
  • Anders Karlsson, Editor-in-Chief of Transport & Logistik iDag (Sweden)
  • Klaus Koch, Editor-in-Chief Logistik&Fördertechnik, Handel Heute (Schweiz)
  • Allan Leibowitz, Editor-in-Chief (Australien)
  • Valeria Lima de Azevedo Nammur, Publisher LOGWEB Magazin (Brasilien)
  • Glenn Lund, Editor-in-Chief of Moderne Transport (Norway)
  • Peter MacLeod, Editor-in-Chief of SHD Logistics (England)
  • Bernd Maienschein, Editor-in-Chief of MM Logistik (Germany)
  • Marilena Matei, Editorial Manager of Tranzit and Tranzit Logistica (Romania)
  • Anton Mizunov, Editor-in-Chief of Skladskoj Komplex (Logistics and Transport) (Russia)
  • Maurizio Peruzzi, Editor-in-Chief of Il Giornale della Logistica (Italy)
  • Isabel Rodrigo, Editor-in-Chief of Logística Profesional (Spain)
  • Hans-Joachim Schlobach, Publisher-Editor and Editor-in-Chief of BUSINESS+LOGISTIC (Austria)
  • Sascha Schmel, Managing Director of the VDMA Materials Handling and Intralogistics Sector Association (without voting rights)
  • Sabine Schulz-Rohde, Editor-in-Chief of Beschaffung aktuell (Germany)
  • Sebastian Śliwieński, Editor-in-Chief of Warehouse Monitor (Poland)
  • Heres Stad, Editor-in-Chief of Logistiek (Netherlands)
  • Jarlath Sweeney, Editor-in-Chief of Fleet Transport (Ireland)
  • Mats Udikas, Editor-in-Chief of Transportnytt (Schweden)

The Executive Jury Chairperson is Anita Würmser, logistics journalist and Managing Director of wuermser.communications. The headquarters of the IFOY Organisation are in Munich.

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.